68 Comments
User's avatar
Erin O'Connor's avatar

Lovely lady novels for troubled times: Dodie Smith, I Capture the Castle! Made me laugh until I couldn't stand it. Also: if you're feeling meditative and regional, Sarah Orne Jewett's Country of the Pointed Firs. Jane Gardam's Crusoe's Daughter. And if we're feeling a little bit Victorian, Mary Elizabeth Braddon, Lady Audley's Secret.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Thank you so much for these recommendations - don't know how I missed your comment before! But these are going straight on the list.

Expand full comment
Vivien Grist's avatar

Loved “I Capture The Castle”. One of my favourite books!

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Yes I love that one too!

Expand full comment
Erin O'Connor's avatar

"I write this while sitting in the kitchen sink." One of the best first sentences ever.

Expand full comment
Vivien Grist's avatar

It is! I can’t think of a better one

Expand full comment
Ellie Phoebe Brown's avatar

Love your suggestions Hats! This is my genre to a T. One of my faves to re-read is Miss Pettigrew Lives For A Day.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Yes that’s a brilliant one, I’m saving it for a later post…

Expand full comment
Win's avatar

Mine too …and Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont and just about everything by Dorothy Whipple …check out Persephone Books catalogue….

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Oh I love Persephone books, I have an embarrassingly large collection! Yes to Dorothy Whipple, I must write about some of hers soon.

Expand full comment
Dawn Sugden's avatar

Absolutely love this book.

Expand full comment
Anna Sayburn Lane's avatar

Utter bliss.

Expand full comment
Caroline Spearing's avatar

Early Angela Thirkell every time! Summer Half (nice young man with delightfully feral sister becomes schoolmaster for a term ); Wild Strawberries (dull girl stays with rich eccentric relatives; falls in love with charming cad); Pomfret Towers (grand house party in Gothic mansion) - well written froth the lot of them.

Expand full comment
Barratt Family's avatar

Love Thirkell. My go-to books of hers are the wartime home front novels, starting with Cheerfulness Breaks In and ending with Peace Breaks Out.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I've read the first but not the last, still working my way through! They're great to read when you need a break from other things, I find.

Expand full comment
Elisabeth Grace Foley's avatar

Oh, yes, absolutely second this! Those titles you mentioned plus High Rising and August Folly are all fluffy "comfort reads" for me.

Expand full comment
Caroline Spearing's avatar

I like the later ones too but they’re more of a specialist taste I think!

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Yes I love Thirkell! August Folly and Wild Strawberries are both great. I like the later ones too but they do start to blur into one another a bit.

Expand full comment
Gretchen's avatar

Yes, I definitely vote for Thirkell and am delighted her novels are back in pring.

Expand full comment
Lizzie Broadbent's avatar

I go to Georgette Heyer - maybe Frederica or The Grand Sophy. Spirited heroines and lots of lovely Regency detail.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Georgette Heyer was a genius - those two (and Cotillion) have to be my favourites as well!

Expand full comment
PDP's avatar

You are doing God's work. If there's a God. I'm split on it. Love the Christie, I think her lighter work is great. When I was a kid I'd amassed so many books that as well a a wall of shelves I slept on top of cupboards built under my bed to store the books I dragged back from jumble sales and second-hand bookshops. Books didn't have to fit into a niche then , so Dashiell Hammet could rub along nicely with James Thurber, Stephen Leacock and Orwell.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Thank you! And I can relate, I used to bring piles and piles of books home from second-hand shops. I find that however many bookshelves you have, you always have slightly too many books to fit on them...

Expand full comment
Vivien Grist's avatar

It is a truth universally acknowledged that a young woman in posession of a lot of books has to buy more books upon entering a bookshop.

Comes to mind

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Always!

Expand full comment
Elisabeth Grace Foley's avatar

I could suggest so many, but here's just two that come to mind:

"Come Out of the Kitchen!" by Alice Duer Miller, a romantic comedy where a young man rents a furnished house for the season, complete with servants...who don't act quite like any servants he's seen before.

"The Story Book Girls" by Christina Gowans Whyte: I feel like maybe only two other people have ever read this book, but it's a lovely, relaxed coming-of-age story with dashes of humor and romance, about a large affectionate family of mostly girls (who are actually *not* the Story Book Girls of the title), their brother, friends, and neighbors.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I have the Story Book Girls! I found it in a pub in Norwich and they let me take it home so I could finish reading it. I actually took it down from the bookshelf the other day as I was thinking about writing about it. When I'm back I'll stick a picture up as it's a great hardback copy with illustrations. I haven't heard of the other but will look it up!

Expand full comment
laura thompson's avatar

Love this! 7 Dials is a blast - Agatha does Bright Young Things...

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

It's just so funny - I love the Cootes and their failure to get the gardener to do what they want

Expand full comment
laura thompson's avatar

Yes! And Lord Caterham being made a director of one of Coote’s companies, ‘they have very nice blotting paper’. It’s really droll.

Expand full comment
Heidi N's avatar

Miss Buncle’s Book (D.E. Stevenson)!

And Cold Comfort Farm

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Both brilliant! I remember reading Miss Buncle's Book as a child and then never being able to find it again, I was so happy that Persephone Books reprinted it.

Expand full comment
Vivien Grist's avatar

Have just ordered Miss Buncle’s Book. Can’t wait to read.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I hope you enjoy it!

Expand full comment
Vivien Grist's avatar

I’m sure I will

Expand full comment
Arden Boshier's avatar

Currently reading the Vita Sackville-West/Nigel Nicolson memoir, Portrait of a Marriage, because what I find most comforting & engrossing is gossip

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I haven't heard of this one but it sounds great, will add it to the list!

Expand full comment
Marianne van Pelt's avatar

This is great!!! Love discovering old books... along the lines of the first category, Hotel du Lac is fun and so is The Enchanted April. For an easy comic romps: anything by PG Wodehouse is spot on, as is Greene's Travels with My Aunt and Auntie Mame, the first novel. So many.... Thanks for this 😊🙏

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I love The Enchanted April, am actually planning on writing about that one soon - and I'd forgotten about Travels With My Aunt which is brilliant so thank you for the reminder! And yes PG Wodehouse is incomparable.

Expand full comment
She's avatar

I suspect you will also really enjoy "Father" by Elizabeth Von Arnim.. a very funny, feel-good read! And free in one of the collected works of Elizabeth Von Arnim on kindle. Also published by Persephone.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I do love Elizabeth von Arnim although I’ve only read a few of hers, I’ll add Father to the top of the list!

Expand full comment
Marianne van Pelt's avatar

Oh fabulous - I look forward to reading that! I also loved her first book, Elizabeth & Her German Garden. Was less enthusiastic about Vera.

Expand full comment
Barratt Family's avatar

I have downloaded Lady Betty and am really enjoying it. I’d never heard of the authors before so I’m looking forward to lots of good reading!

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I’m so glad you like it!

Expand full comment
Barb's avatar

Love learning and reading old books. Thanks so much

This will keep me busy!!

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

You're very welcome, I hope you enjoy them!

Expand full comment
Hannah Gridley's avatar

Ah, I have read and loved all of these except the Agatha Christie one! Definitely would recommend them.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

We obviously have similar taste! If you like the others then you should definitely give Christie a try.

Expand full comment
Jennie Lutton's avatar

I'm loving this list and going through it one by one with my Libby Library App. Thanks so much!

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

You’re most welcome! I hope you find something that becomes a favourite!

Expand full comment
Resh Susan's avatar

Really enjoyed this list.

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

I’m so glad! There are some of my favourites in there.

Expand full comment
Mariella Hunt's avatar

I’ve never heard of these, but the excerpts sound intriguing. I’ll have to check them out! Thanks for the recs!

Expand full comment
Harriet's avatar

Thanks for reading! I hope you find something new you love…

Expand full comment